Category Archives: fourfolds

Plato’s Fourfold Vision in the Phaedrus

In Plato’s Phaedrus, this “fourfold vision” refers to four distinct types of divine madness or inspiration; and being of divine origination are associated with various Greek gods. These are: prophecy from Apollon (later, Roman Apollo), mystic rites (telestic madness) from Dionysus (Bacchus), poetry and arts from the Muses (Camenæ), and love from Aphrodite and Eros (Venus and Cupid). These different forms of divine madness are seen as beneficial blessings and essential for a fulfilling life, crucial for living well and having a deeper connection to truth and beauty.

Also in the Phaedrus is Plato’s theory of the soul, most famously utilizing the metaphor of a chariot driven by two horses. The four types of divine madness represent different ways the soul can be uplifted. They are powers that can help guide the charioteer, steering the soul towards its higher purpose. If the soul follows the divine, the charioteer can ascend to the “plain of truth” (i.e. the realm of Plato’s Forms.) If not, the soul falls to earth in human form. The better the soul has seen truth, the higher will be its place in its “next” life.

It’s kind of odd that the charioteer is supposed to embody Reason, in order to steer the chariot’s horses properly, and yet there is no divine madness specifically associated with reason. Where is Athena (Roman Minerva), to aid the soul in its journey, as a guide for Reason? Perhaps Plato thought that Apollon could serve double duty, as he was thought to also symbolize reason as well as prophecy. Or perhaps the very notion of “divine madness” should not be associated with reasoning and logic. I disagree.

The writings of Benjamin Labatut come to mind as showcases of the “divine madness” of reason and logic. Various persons of science and mathematics are written about in a pseudo-bibliographical way: the mathematician Alexander Grothendieck, the computer scientist John von Neumann, and others. Other writers have also written about those that live in the highest realms of logic and mathematics: Kurt Godel, Grigory Perelman, etc. Their intellect may put them close to a form of madness.

Note:

I’ve chosen the Roman names for these Greek gods for the sole reason that they fit better in my diagram. I hope it’s not too confusing.

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phaedrus_(dialogue)

PLATO’S PHAEDRUS: FOUR TYPES OF DIVINE MADNESS

View at Medium.com

View at Medium.com

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muses

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benjam%C3%ADn_Labatut

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Grothendieck

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann

Matthew Shelton / Divine Madness in Plato’s Phaedrus

https://www.academia.edu/118753337/Divine_Madness_in_Plato_s_Phaedrus

Katja Maria Vogt / Plato on Madness and the Good Life

Click to access paper-vogt-plato-on-madness-and-the-good-life.pdf

<>

 

Plato’s Fourfold Division in the Philebus

In Plato’s dialogue the Philebus, Socrates uses a fourfold division to describe fundamental, metaphysical principles of all things: the Unlimited (ápeiron, the indefinite, boundless aspect), the Limited (péras, the definite aspect of measure and boundary), the Mixture of these two (meikton, a combined indefinite-definite), and the Cause of the mixture (aitia, which gives structure to the mixture and is responsible for unifying it).

This framework provides the foundation for the dialogue’s central argument about what constitutes the good life, and what activity is best to achieve it. In the dialogue, Socrates uses the four parts of the division to examine the natures of both pleasure and reason, determining that their mixture, brought about by some cause, is the key to a truly good life. So neither pleasure alone, nor reason alone, would suffice.

This fourfold division reminds me of Aristotle’s later schema of the Four Causes. Initially I thought that the Unbounded could be the Material Cause, the Bounded could be Formal Cause, the Mixture could be Final Cause, and finally the Cause could be Efficient Cause. That is because one might think that there is always more material to be had if you want it, and the form of a project puts shape, constraints, limits, and relationships on it.

However, I now believe that what is truly limited is the raw material (matter, energy, time, information), and what is unlimited is all possible form (and not any one particular form). The combinations or permutations that one can make from a finite set of elements are essentially unlimited in number, or at least increase exponentially with the length of the permutation or the size of the combination.

Consider the finite nature of an alphabet, and the endless number of sentences that can be formed from it. Or think about the four DNA base pairs, and the endless variety of genes and organisms that can be generated from them. Remember Darwin’s quote: “Endless forms most beautiful”. Of course many of sentences one can make are gibberish, and many of the organisms one could make are not fit or even viable.

I realize that in Plato’s dialogue the Unlimited and the Limited are more about the continuous and the discrete: the infinite and the finite, the unbounded and the bounded, the indefinite and the definite. The examples of the Unlimited given have the common aspect of “more and less”, i.e. they are indeterminant. By contrast, the examples of the Limit(ed) are of a determinant nature, a bound, a limit, a fixation, a stop to the “more and less”.

It seems that one could spent an unlimited amount of time studying the intricacies of the Philebus and thinking about the meaning of it. But I am starting to feel that my time is indeed limited and other matters require my attention. I know I am probably at odds with all others in the proper interpretation of this part of the dialogue. At least you might enjoy the limited links I have provided, and you still have the unlimited freedom to make of them what you will.

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philebus

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1744/1744-h/1744-h.htm

https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/plato/dialogues/benjamin-jowett/text/philebus

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plato-ethics/

Mary Louise Gill / The Fourfold Division of Beings (Philebus 23b-27c)

https://www.academia.edu/40402669/The_Fourfold_Division_of_Beings_Gill_on_Platos_Philebus_

Ashley Lascano / A critical analysis of the metaphysics of limit and unlimited in Plato’s Philebus

https://commons.lib.jmu.edu/honors201019/691/

George Rudebusch / Philebus 23c-26d: Peras, Apeiron, and Meikton as Measure Theory

https://impactum-journals.uc.pt/platojournal/article/view/10332

<>

The Four Evangelists

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Evangelists

Brief History of the Analogy of the Four Evangelists to the Four Living Creatures

Behold, the Tetramorph

Exuberant Hungarian: The Art of Matthias Church, Budapest

https://artmuseum.princeton.edu/art/collections/objects/33564

Essay on the Four Evangelists written by Claude.AI:

https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/d727367e-e9be-4087-b0e3-d5d1ee9d4c9d

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synoptic_Gospels

<>

Don’t Be Square!

Being square can mean being either good or bad, depending on the context. For the good aspect, square can mean being aligned correctly or being even or balanced in some measure. For the bad aspect, square can mean being old-fashioned or not in step with the times.

Many things that are constructed by humans are square or rectangular in shape: furniture, buildings, books, shipping containers, newspapers, game boards. Many things are also constructed as grids: fabrics, streets, cities, microchips. Even virtual things such as computer windowing systems (GUIs) are right-angled for the most part.

By contrast, almost nothing in nature is square or rectangular. There are exceptions, of course, such as some crystals, geological formations, or even some animal eye pupils. Other regular shapes are preferred, such as the hexagonal tiling of a honeycomb, the six-fold symmetry of the snowflake, the pentagonal symmetry of the starfish, etc.

Often human-made things that diverge from a square or rectangular shape catch the eye or are innovative. Buckminster Fuller became famous due to his geodesic dome. Architect Frank Gehry comes to mind by his design of irregular buildings. Other architects designed shapes that looked more natural because of their fluid and organic appearance.

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_(disambiguation)

Hannah B. Higgins / The Grid book

The Riddle of the Square:

https://www.chrbutler.com/square

Are we square? If so, our exchange is somehow “equivalent” in value.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_(slang)

Flatland: As told by a Square:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flatland

Square meals are healthier than … unsquare ones!

https://wordsmarts.com/square-meal/

An essay written by Claude.AI on squareness:

https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/363e91aa-d1d6-449e-b802-620491e37ce2

<>

The Golden Touch

Not everything that is golden is to be desired. Sometimes gold can represent greed or excess in itself, the corruption that wealth and power can bring. Gold has long been coveted by those of status; the legend of King Midas is a case in point. Everything he touched turned to gold, including his food and his daughter.

Golden items often figure into myths: the Golden Idol, the Golden Calf, the Golden Apples, the Golden Fleece, the Golden Hind, the Golden Ass. I have already talked about several golden concepts of ethics or morals, the Golden Mean and the Golden Rule. And the Golden Ratio is a valorized concept of geometry, art, and architecture.

So to round out (or square up) my golden theme, the Golden Touch may serve as my culmination. Other golden things can be brought to mind, but I settled on the concept of the title. The Golden Touch can be thought to represent the dark side of Gold!

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midas

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Idol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_calf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Fleece

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_apple

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Golden_Ass

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceryneian_Hind

Essay written by Claude.AI about the negativities of gold.

https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/2ae11e87-3281-4319-95a3-54d3a87d9c8f

[*14.100]

<>

The Golden Mean

The Golden Mean is the desirable middle ground between two extremes of behavior, one of excess and the other of deficiency. It appeared in Greece at least as early as the Delphic maxim “nothing in excess”, which was discussed by Plato. Aristotle analyzed the Golden Mean by saying that the virtues of character can be described as means between having too much and having too little. For example, courage is a virtue in the Aristotelian view, being the mean between recklessness (too much) and cowardice (too little).

  • Excess
  • Dearth
  • Virtue
  • Mean

The Mean between Excess and Dearth is Virtue!

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_mean_(philosophy)

https://philosophybreak.com/articles/the-golden-mean-aristotle-guide-to-living-excellently/

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-ethics/

Aristotle’s Politics: The Politics of the Golden Mean

[*14.98]

<>

 

The Golden Rule

As I continue my breadth-first search for every fourth thing, please enjoy the following:

The Golden Rule, an ethics of reciprocity, has a long and valued history in many cultures, but seems to have fallen into disfavor recently in these United States. Why is that, I wonder? Too expensive? Too much trouble? Too what, exactly?

Recall:

Do unto others, like you would have them do unto you.

or

Don’t do to others, what you wouldn’t want them to do to you.

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule

The Golden Rule

https://philosophynow.org/issues/74/The_Golden_Rule_Not_So_Golden_Anymore

<>

Edgar Schein’s Four Principles of Organization

What are the four principles of organizing? Google search led me to:

Edgar Schein, a prominent organizational psychologist, identified four key elements of an organization’s structure: common purpose, coordinated effort, division of labor, and hierarchy of authority. Each of the four elements represents an essential component of an effective structure.

Further Reading:

The Purpose of Organization

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Schein

<>

Some Thoughts on Mazes and Labyrinths

Some classify labyrinths as unicursal and mazes as multicursal, but I don’t think this is standard terminology, and often the terms are used interchangeably for each other. Four elements may be common to both: doors or gates to enter and leave, turns to the left or right, forks in the path going two or more ways, and dead ends or stops. Unicursal labyrinths only have doors and turns, whereas multicursal mazes have all four.

A maze or labyrinth can be a metaphor for our experience of time. A block universe, where time is determined from its very beginning, can be modelled by a unicursal labyrinth that winds back and forth but leads ultimately to its final end. An open universe where time divides endlessly depending upon actions and choices can be modelled by a multicursal maze full of forks, dead ends and maybe loops, but may also have many paths to its many ends.

Multicursal designs may also have loops, where one can return to a location without turning around and going back. But a loop is part of the global pattern, and not discernable from any local inspection. There is a strategy for maze navigation called the right-hand-rule, which perhaps works for multicursal designs without loops. Any fork in a multicursal maze must be considered as a decision to make.

An interesting myth that I ran across is Hercules at the Crossroads. A crossroads is an intersection of two roads, and so allows the traveler to turn to the left, the right, or perhaps continue straight. One cannot divide oneself to go two or three ways at once and so must choose. Perhaps the myth should have been called Hercules at the Fork in the Road, but that’s not as catchy.

Some labyrinths have no walls, but are just laid out as a design on the floor of a cathedral or other building. I think these are mostly unicursal, but I’m not sure. A person may enjoy the experience of walking through the design, taking the twists and turns as they come, and being lost in the middle for a while, but then finally emerging at last. Success!

Other mazes may be constructed by hedges or in corn fields, and so are outside and open to the elements. Another style of outdoor maze is the turf maze, which only has short turf greenery for its walls that can be stepped over. Many formal gardens of large estates had hedge or turf mazes in them. Also, many of the so-called crop circles were also maze-like in their layout.

The classic text adventure game Colossal Cave, besides being a maze of sorts, contains two mazes inside of it, one that describes each room by saying “You are in a maze of twisty little passages, all alike” and one that changes each room description sightly. One must use paper and pencil to map them out unless one has a very good memory.

Some of the very first computer games with graphics also took place in a maze, like Castle Wolfenstein. These were usually first-person shooter type games. It was easiest to draw the simple perspective and hidden lines of a receding corridor with turns and doors than some elaborate building interior. Plus, monsters or enemies that could suddenly jump out and threaten you were easily programmed.

There’s more that can complicate a maze or labyrinth. The lighting can be poor, or nonexistent. There can be hidden doors or traps. Monsters or enemies could emerge suddenly. A maze or labyrinth can be three dimensional, with stairs or ramps or holes. There may be requirements to be able to proceed to unexplored parts. Found hints or clues may also benefit the maze goer.

Further Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedge_maze

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_maze

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turf_maze

https://publicdomainreview.org/collection/mazes-and-labyrinths-1922/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colossal_Cave_Adventure

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Wolfenstein

<>

Hercules at the Crossroads

The story of Heracles (Hercules) at the Crossroads is one of the most profound and enduring moral allegories in ancient Greek mythology. This tale embodies the quintessential struggle between virtue and vice, encapsulating a universal theme that resonates across cultures and generations: the challenge of making life-defining choices. The allegory not only highlights the moral and ethical dimensions of human existence but also offers insight into the complexities of character development and the paths to true fulfillment.

The Story of Heracles at the Crossroads

The story originates from the ancient philosopher Prodicus and has been retold by various classical authors, including Xenophon. It describes a pivotal moment in the life of Heracles, the celebrated hero known for his exceptional strength and his legendary Twelve Labors. As the tale goes, when Heracles was a young man, he reached a crossroads where two goddesses appeared to him, each representing a different path.

One goddess, named Kakia (Vice), promised him a life of ease, luxury, and immediate gratification. She depicted a future filled with indulgence and comfort, free from hardship and struggle. Her voice was alluring, and her promises seemed tempting to a young man eager for enjoyment without toil.

The other goddess, Arete (Virtue), offered a starkly different vision. She spoke of a path defined by toil, sacrifice, and perseverance. Arete promised that while this path would be difficult and fraught with challenges, it would lead to true glory, respect, and lasting fulfillment. The road she offered was steep and treacherous, but it was the path that would bring out the best in Heracles.

Symbolism and Themes

At its core, Heracles at the Crossroads is rich in symbolism, encapsulating the eternal human conflict between short-term pleasures and long-term achievements. The two goddesses embody the dual aspects of human nature: the pull of immediate desires versus the pursuit of higher values and goals. Heracles’ choice is a metaphor for the decisions each person must make at critical junctures in their own lives.

Choosing Kakia’s path represents succumbing to the allure of ease and self-indulgence, which, although pleasant in the short term, ultimately leads to stagnation and dissatisfaction. Arete’s path, on the other hand, illustrates the rewards that come from embracing challenges and persisting in the face of adversity. The story implicitly teaches that true heroism is not found in physical feats alone but in the moral courage to choose the harder right over the easier wrong.

Heracles’ Decision and Its Consequences

Heracles’ choice to follow Arete, the path of Virtue, set the course for his legendary life. The decision signified his commitment to a life defined by effort and purpose. This choice not only elevated him to the status of a hero but also embedded in his narrative the idea that true greatness is achieved through perseverance and moral integrity. Each of Heracles’ subsequent labors—whether slaying the Nemean Lion, capturing the Golden Hind, or cleansing the Augean stables—became both a literal and figurative testament to the virtues he chose to uphold at the crossroads.

The allegory reinforces the notion that real fulfillment and glory are earned, not given. Heracles’ victories were the culmination of hard work, bravery, and self-sacrifice. His choice serves as a reminder that while the path of virtue may be difficult, it is ultimately the most rewarding. This lesson continues to inspire and provide moral guidance, encouraging individuals to strive for excellence even when the path is arduous.

Relevance in Modern Context

The themes of Heracles at the Crossroads are as relevant today as they were in ancient times. Modern society, with its constant barrage of instant gratification through technology and convenience, often mirrors Kakia’s promises. The pressures to seek out shortcuts to success, avoid discomfort, and chase fleeting pleasures are as powerful now as they were in the days of Heracles.

However, Arete’s message remains equally significant: true accomplishment and a meaningful life come from making choices that align with one’s values and principles, even if those choices are demanding. Whether it is pursuing a challenging career path, maintaining integrity in difficult situations, or dedicating oneself to a cause greater than personal gain, the allegory of Heracles’ choice continues to resonate as a symbol of the importance of resilience and moral strength.

Conclusion

The story of Heracles at the Crossroads is an enduring allegory that imparts the timeless lesson of choosing virtue over vice. Heracles’ decision to follow the path of Arete over Kakia not only laid the foundation for his legendary status but also provided a model of moral fortitude that continues to inspire countless generations. In every crossroads that life presents, the essence of this myth invites individuals to choose not just the path of least resistance but the one that leads to true fulfillment and greatness. It reminds us that while the path of virtue may be steep and challenging, it is ultimately the path that shapes heroes.

Thanks again, ChatGPT! I admit that I hesitated to share this little article of yours, but I thought it was worthwhile and thought others might appreciate it as well. However, perhaps I’m choosing the path of ease in asking for your help, instead of the chore of writing this essay myself.

Futher Reading:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hercules_at_the_crossroads

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kakia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arete

Hercules at the Crossroads

Images of Hercules at the Crossroads

Also, music!

<>