There was a fourfold making the rounds a while back about belief and knowledge of God or of gods. The terms Agnostic and Gnostic are about (the actuality or possibility of) having or not having knowledge, whereas Theist and Atheist are about having or not having belief in a deity or deities. So the following fourfold obtains:
- Gnostic Atheist
- Agnostic Atheist
- Gnostic Theist
- Agnostic Theist
Some criticized this framework, while others seemed to like it. YMMV.
Let’s see what ChatGPT says:
Gnostic Atheist: This term refers to someone who believes that God does not exist, and that this knowledge is certain. They have a definite and confident understanding about the non-existence of God.
Agnostic Atheist: This term refers to someone who doesn’t believe in God, but does not claim to have certainty about it. They may lack knowledge or certainty about the existence of God, but they do not believe in its existence.
Gnostic Theist: This term refers to someone who believes in the existence of God and has a definite and confident understanding about it. They have a strong conviction that God exists.
Agnostic Theist: This term refers to someone who believes in God but does not claim to have certainty or absolute knowledge about it. They have a belief in God, but acknowledge that it is not possible to have certain knowledge or proof of God’s existence.
In summary, “Gnostic” refers to knowledge or certainty, while “Agnostic” refers to lack of knowledge or certainty. The “Atheist” and “Theist” refer to the belief or non-belief in the existence of a higher power or deity, respectively.
Further Reading:
Other images:
https://www.google.com/search?q=gnostic+atheist+theist+agnostic&tbm=isch
For example:
I also see the following fourfold used (all nouns now):
- Atheist
- Theist
- Gnostic
- Agnostic
and even this eight-fold (a combination of the two):
- Gnostic Atheist
- Atheist
- Agnostic Atheist
- Agnostic
- Agnostic Theist
- Theist
- Gnostic Theist
- Gnostic
<>
Like YMMV. Haven’t heard that slogan in a while. Almost looks like a relative of YHWH. And if you’re wondering where I fall in the fourfold, probably agnostic theist.
I guess if I had to pick one, it’d be agnostic atheist.